Siesta Key Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving Day marks the season when we come together with our cherished ones, savoring succulent turkey, savory stuffing, and delectable pumpkin pie. All the while, we express appreciation for the blessings in our lives. This treasured custom brings a sense of warmth to our hearts and satisfies our appetites.

But what if you find yourself away from home, perhaps on the beautiful shores of Siesta Key, Florida? Fear not, because we have the perfect solution to make your  Thanksgiving in Siesta Key just as memorable, if not more so!

While some may opt for the familiar routine of preparing a feast in their vacation rental, there’s another delightful option: dining out. Imagine ditching the hassle of grocery shopping, prepping, and cleaning up and instead, savoring the holiday spirit in a relaxed, festive setting. Trust us, Siesta Key is a hidden gem when it comes to enjoying a delectable holiday meal.

If you’re ready to embark on a culinary adventure and celebrate in style, join us as we explore the best Siesta Key restaurants open on Thanksgiving!

In this blog post, we’ve scoured the Siesta Key area to bring you a selection of the finest restaurants where you can relish a Thanksgiving dinner like no other. From oceanfront eateries with panoramic views to cozy, family-friendly spots, Siesta Key has a variety of dining experiences that are sure to please your palate and create lasting holiday memories. Get ready to enjoy a memorable and hassle-free Siesta Key Thanksgiving dinner!

The Capital Grille

The Capital Grille is undoubtedly one of the top choices for a Thanksgiving feast in Siesta Key. 

Renowned nationwide for its exquisite dry-aged steaks, chops, and seafood, it promises an unforgettable holiday experience.

What sets The Capital Grille apart is its dedication to culinary perfection. Their steaks are dry-aged in-house for 18 to 24 days and expertly hand-cut by their skilled on-site butcher and, with a wine list boasting over 350 selections and a wine kiosk housing thousands of bottles, it’s a haven for wine enthusiasts.

For Thanksgiving, The Capital Grille offers a chef-prepared dinner featuring Turkey with Brioche stuffing, French green beans with Marcona almonds, cranberry-pear chutney, and mashed potatoes. And, of course, don’t forget to save room for their irresistible Pumpkin Cheesecake!

Located at The Mall at UTC on 140 University Town Center Drive in Sarasota, Florida, The Capital Grille is the perfect destination for a Thanksgiving celebration that combines elegance, superb cuisine and a warm holiday ambiance

Der Dutchman

Der Dutchman is a highly recommended restaurant near Siesta Key for those seeking a traditional Thanksgiving meal with a warm, homey touch. 

This family-owned establishment, hailing from Ohio and specializing in Amish and Mennonite cuisine, has made a name for itself in Sarasota’s Pinecraft neighborhood. On Thanksgiving, Der Dutchman opens its doors from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., offering a bountiful buffet that includes turkey, ham, roast beef, mashed potatoes, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and more. It’s an all-you-can-eat extravaganza that captures the essence of a classic holiday feast.

If you’re yearning for the comforts of a Thanksgiving at home you can pre-order a carry-out package and savor it in the cozy confines of your Siesta Key vacation rental.

Located at 3713 Bahia Vista St in Sarasota, FL, Der Dutchman embodies the spirit of Thanksgiving with its hearty fare and welcoming atmosphere; the perfect place to experience the joy of the holiday, even when you’re away from home.

Duval’s

Duval’s, Sarasota’s reigning Best Seafood Restaurant for eight consecutive years, is an exceptional Thanksgiving dining choice located at 1435 Main St in downtown Sarasota. 

Whether you prefer to dine in or enjoy a family-style Thanksgiving feast in the comfort of your own space, Duval’s has something special in store for you. Duval’s offers “The Feast” on Thanksgiving Day; a culinary journey that begins with a house salad, cornbread, and rolls served family-style, followed by a generous plate filled with all the classic Thanksgiving fixings. 

Picture herb and butter-roasted turkey with pan gravy, along with brown sugar and mustard-glazed ham. The sides include creamy mashed potatoes, the chef’s signature stuffing, green beans, carrots, roasted sweet potato casserole, and zesty orange-ginger cranberry sauce. To top it all off, the dessert features a choice between pumpkin and Key lime pie.

If you’d rather enjoy “The Feast” at home, Duval’s has you covered too. This delicious spread serves four to five and even includes a whole pumpkin pie, with the option to pair it with select wines. 

Whether you’re looking for an exquisite dining experience or a delightful Thanksgiving spread to-go, Duval’s offers the perfect solution to make your holiday memorable.

Harry’s

Harry’s is another fantastic choice for your Thanksgiving Day celebration. This restaurant is open on Thanksgiving from 2 pm to 8 pm, offering a delightful three-course dinner experience that’s sure to make your holiday special.

The first course presents two delectable options: Five Spiced Butternut Squash Soup with a drizzle of maple syrup and spiced pecans or a refreshing Fall Apple Salad featuring Fiji apples, Craisins, cherry tomatoes, spiced pecans, baby spinach, crispy shallots, and zesty lemon-honey vinaigrette.

The centerpiece of your feast is a mouthwatering Fresh Roasted Turkey, accompanied by Apple-Walnut Stuffing, Giblet Gravy, Cranberry Relish, and Fresh Green Beans Almondine, served with a side of Mashed Idaho and Sweet Potatoes. 

To round off your meal, you get to choose from a delectable trio of desserts: Traditional Pumpkin Pie, Apple Cheesecake, or Chocolate Pecan Pie. With its inviting ambiance and scrumptious Thanksgiving menu, Harry’s is the perfect spot to create lasting holiday memories with friends and family. 

Miguel’s

Experience Thanksgiving with a European twist at Miguel’s Restaurant, where French and continental cuisine take center stage. 

On Thanksgiving Day, Miguel’s opens its doors at noon, offering both its regular menu and special Thanksgiving offerings. 

You can savor a three-course turkey and ham special complete with all the traditional trimmings, your choice of soup or salad, and a classic Thanksgiving dessert. Whether you prefer indoor or outdoor dining or want to enjoy your meal from the comfort of your home, Miguel’s Restaurant ensures a memorable Thanksgiving celebration at 6631 Midnight Pass Road in Sarasota. 

Stay With Siesta Key Luxury Rental Properties

When you choose Siesta Key Luxury Rental Properties for your vacation accommodation, you’re not just booking a place to stay; you’re reserving a piece of the Siesta Key experience itself. What sets us apart is our unwavering commitment to guest satisfaction. Our vacation rentals are more than just beautifully decorated spaces; they’re equipped with upgraded amenities like gourmet kitchens, elevators, and heated pools. 

Whether you’re traveling with family, friends, or even furry companions, our rentals are designed to be your home away from home. What’s more, you’ll have a dedicated property manager by your side, ensuring a personal touch from reservation to check-out.

If you’re traveling with a large group, our 7+ bedroom Siesta Key rentals are a dream come true with enough room to accommodate up to 25 people while providing both privacy and communal spaces to create cherished memories. 

On the other hand, our 1-2 bedroom rentals in Siesta Key cater to individuals, couples, or small families seeking a luxurious Sunshine State getaway. At Siesta Key Luxury Rental Properties, we take pride in being the top vacation rental management business in the area. Come and experience Siesta Key like never before, where your stay is not just about a place to sleep but about creating lasting memories in a home away from home.