Siesta Key Restaurants

While on your stay in Siesta Key you will certainly notice the only thing as commonplace as the friendly people on the key is the number of restaurants to choose from. Measuring just 3.5 square miles in size, this yearlong vacation getaway offers superb dining options with a wide variety of cuisines. Just a short walk from our many of the vacation rentals is the Siesta Village area, one of the key’s premier restaurant locations. Siesta Key restaurants offer travelers the epitome of great vacation food, and this is what you can expect while you are vacationing on Siesta Key.

Restaurants Near Siesta Key

Convenience and Cost

One of the major reasons why people dine out on vacation is to enjoy themselves without having to worry about the prep or cleaning up of their meals. Restaurants in the Siesta Village area price their menus to make this choice both easy and affordable and are conveniently located a short drive or walk away from most Siesta Key Vacation Rentals. Instead of spending hours in the kitchen preparing for meals that time can be spent on the beach enjoying your time at Siesta Key. What is not to love about convenient, cost-effective dining in paradise?

Trying Something New!

One of the great aspects of traveling is the ability to try all sorts of new cuisines, and this domestic island is a foodie’s paradise. The island’s secluded feeling really transfers into the whole vacation experience; Siesta Key is growing in popularity for a reason. Try not to let the size of the island fool you, Siesta Key restaurants line the coast and are sure to excite all types of palates. Over 30 independent restaurants can be found in the Siesta Village area, just minutes from Siesta Key Vacation Rentals. The following restaurants are all found in the Siesta Village area and are recommended by both locals and travelers alike.

The Lobster Pot

Keeping the New England tradition of excellence alive, this American seafood joint hits all the points and is a wonderful Siesta Key restaurant for any seafood lover. The friendly staff and excellent, fresh, seafood come together at The Lobster Pot to create one of the top seafood dining experiences in Florida, and at a convenient distance from most Siesta Key Vacation Rentals and vacation homes. Sourcing its ingredients from local farms, The Lobster Pot is a great place to enjoy a delicious meal in a classy yet casual setting. The live lobsters are brought in daily from Bar Harbor and Boothbay Maine to keep true to New England standards of service. Also featured on the menu you will find cod, mahi-mahi, haddock and salmon. If you are in search of the perfect seafood restaurant look no further!

Siesta Key Restaurants

The Hub Baja Grill

Not interested in cooking after a day on the beach? No problem, the Hub Baja Grill is one of the many Siesta Village area restaurants you can easily visit straight after a day on the beach. This local favorite restaurant features a fresh Baja menu with Latin American and tropical inspired entrées. The restaurant’s name hints that it is one of the busier places on the island, as it is a hub for music and comradery. This top rated Siesta Key restaurant has a great energy about it that the whole party can enjoy. Both the lunch and dinner menus feature fresh catches and a variety of well-priced entrées — something for everyone to enjoy!

Another Broken Egg Cafe

The king of breakfast in Siesta Key, Another Broken Egg Café combines an appetizing selection of fresh ingredients to create an incredibly flavorful experience and is one of the highest rated Siesta Key restaurants. A favorite dish is the Bacquezo, a cream cheese and bacon filled omelet with breakfast chorizo, Monterey Jack and green onions. Feeding your indulgent side before noon is something the chefs at Another Broken Egg Café have mastered and is a great change to typical breakfast entrées. Furthermore, the convenient location near many vacation rentals makes it a perfect option for lazy mornings.

Napoli’s Italian Restaurant

This popular Italian restaurant is a major change of pace from the island’s seafood scene; however, it will surprise you with the affordability of their menu and generous portion sizes. Not only is this dining option located within the Siesta Village area; it is also situated on the main road in Siesta Key, offering lots of passing activity and excitement. The menu offers a fairly standard selection of Italian dishes which are all executed masterfully, making the best use of fresh ingredients. Whether you seek a taste of Italy or wholesome feel good food, Napoli’s is a great stop.

Siesta Key Restaurants

The Cottage Restaurant

If you are looking for a more formal seafood dining experience, the Cottage Restaurant is definitely something to notice. This tapas bar and restaurant features a dynamic menu with local flavors. The quality of service is high amongst Siesta Key restaurants, and this restaurant pays special attention to its guests. Quick seating and a responsive, knowledgeable wait staff really make the difference in taking this dining experience to the next level. Whether you are vacationing with friends or family, this local favorite offers outstanding food and service that is sure to blow you away.

Siesta Key Oyster Bar

We know where you should go even if raw oysters aren’t your favorite seafood dish. Siesta Key Oyster Bar (SKOB) is a delightful pub restaurant featuring everything from pork chops, lobster, tacos and chorizo. Try cooked or raw oysters for the first time, or dive in if you’re a long time lover of oysters bars. The casual dining is great for brunch, lunch or dinner with a selection of beers, wine and cocktails with live music entertainment.

No Frills Year-Round Dining Experience

Dining in Siesta Key is highlighted by the front of the house staff in their attention to detail and commitment to customer service. Siesta Key restaurants understand the importance of providing what each customer wants and great service. What is incredible is that although the restaurants of Siesta Key remain affordable, their customer service and dining experience continues to be exceptional.

These are just a few of the top dining options in Siesta Key, and you’ll find plenty more on the island. No matter where you book your vacation rental or other lodging choice with Siesta Key Vacation Rentals, you’ll get to choose from several top rated restaurants nearby to suit your tastes.

Siesta Key Pet-Friendly Restaurants

siesta key pet friendly restaurants

It can be hard to take a break from your furry family member for a vacation, and it can be difficult to find a quality dog-sitter or kennel. You don’t have to worry about that when you choose one of our pet-friendly vacation rentals on Siesta Key and bring Fido along. Siesta Key accommodates your Read More

Where to Find Craft Beer Near Siesta Key?

craft breweries near siesta key

Visiting micro breweries may be extremely popular now, but Sarasota and Siesta Key have been at it for decades. You can visit some of the most authentic breweries in Florida and get a taste of some fantastic craft beers right by the gulf. Where can you find craft beer in and around Siesta Key? Below Read More

5 Unique Restaurants Near Siesta Key

5 crazy restaurants near siesta key

When visiting the beautiful beaches of Siesta Key, it’s essential to try out some of the nearby eclectic, unique and fun local restaurants that have made Southwest Florida a cuisine hub. These restaurants utilize the region’s incredible produce, seafood and meat in delightful ways and have their own distinct character. Some offer eclectic settings and Read More

Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar on Siesta Key

Flavio's Brick Oven and Bar

There’s no shortage of solid pizza places on and around Siesta Key. But what is the point of a “good” pizza when you can get an exceptional pizza? This is the kind of question Chef Flavio would ask you. Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar is an authentic pizzeria and bar run by its lead chef Read More

5 Amazing Siesta Key Italian Restaurants

flavios italian restuarant on siesta key

Think Siesta Key, that beautiful barrier island off the coast of Sarasota, and you’re probably going to think of beaches first. That white quartz sand and clear blue water. Fun beach activities ranging from surfing to kayaking. Lying in the sun, unwinding and forgetting your troubles. But if you’re vacationing on Siesta Key, there’s so Read More

5 Top Rated Siesta Village Family Friendly Restaurants

siesta key ice cream

Take a step back in time to a quieter and more relaxed life, where lazy afternoons on the beach were not burdened by 24/7 news and finding the next great restaurant didn’t require a mobile app. Siesta Key is the throwback beach town you have longed for off the coast of Florida, and Siesta Key Read More

5 of the Top Restaurants Near Siesta Key for Thanksgiving

siesta key restaurant

Thanksgiving Day is all about spending quality time with family and enjoying delicious traditional home cooking. But what happens if you’re on vacation? You really only have two options: taking care of it yourself as usual or dining out. You can navigate your way to the nearest grocery store, find all the ingredients you need, Read More

4 Must-Visit Siesta Village Bars and Pubs

oyster bar

Decorated with powdery quartz-white sand and sparkling blue waters, Siesta Key is one of the best spots in America where you can enjoy complete relaxation and rejuvenation. This laid-back barrier island offers visitors endless opportunities to enjoy a range of attractions on vacation. One of the activities you can find worthwhile is visiting the local Read More

5 Best Drinks to Get on Siesta Key

siesta key bars

Tourists young and old are always searching for destinations like Siesta Key, where local culture blends seamlessly with a tropical paradise. There are many great bars and clubs and other Siesta Key nightlife destinations to choose from while you vacation here. Our island nightlife spots offer some of the Sarasota area’s best live music, drinking Read More


Siesta Key Luxury Rental Properties
5111 Ocean Blvd. Suite B, C & D
Siesta Key, Florida USA 34242
#SiestaKeyLuxury #iHeartSiestaKey